Email Us
12.09.2024
Brooke Kirshne
When it comes to maintaining good indoor air quality, selecting the right air filter for your HVAC system is crucial. Two of the most common types of air filters used in residential settings are fiberglass and pleated filters. Each type offers different advantages and disadvantages depending on factors like filtration efficiency, cost, and compatibility with your system.
Choosing the right filter can be confusing, with factors such as price and performance to consider. In this blog, we will explore the differences between fiberglass and pleated air filters, helping you understand their benefits and limitations. By the end, you'll be able to make the right choice on what type of filter is most suitable for your needs.
What Are Fiberglass Air Filters?
Fiberglass filters are made from materials such as spun glass or non-woven glass fibers. These filters are often referred to as disposable filters, as they are designed to be replaced after use. Spun glass is created by melting silica, lime, and sodium together, then blowing the mixture to form fine glass threads. Non-woven fiberglass, on the other hand, is produced by using a high-pressure jet of water to entangle the fibers together. Both of these materials are fragile, which makes fiberglass filters relatively delicate.
Fiberglass filters typically have a MERV (Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value) rating between 1 and 4, indicating that they offer basic filtration, which is suitable for residential use. They are effective at trapping larger particles, but they are not designed to capture finer dust, pollen, or other smaller contaminants. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of fiberglass filters:
Advantages
- Budget-Friendly: One of the key advantages of fiberglass filters is that they are highly affordable, with prices varying depending on the supplier, size and quality.
- Availability: Fiberglass filters are easily available at most hardware stores, so you can purchase them when your old filter needs a replacement.
- Airflow: Using a fiberglass filter for your HVAC system can be beneficial in terms of airflow. These filters let the air pass through them easily, and due to this, your HVAC unit works properly.
- Eliminates Large Particles: The efficiency of eliminating large airborne particles from the air is the main benefit of a fiberglass filter. So these filters are suited for those who want a decent level of filtration in their home.
Disadvantages
- MERV Ratings: Fiberglass filters have a MERV rating between 1 and 4, which may not be ideal for those seeking a higher level of filtration, such as protection against smaller particles like dust and pollen.
- Lifespan: The life of fiberglass filters is very short and you can use these filters only for 30 days. This is one of the main disadvantages because you will be replacing your filters more often.
- Low Quality: The materials that are used to make fiberglass filters are very low quality; that's the reason they have a chance of getting damaged easily, which can cause problems for your HVAC system.
- Filtration Capacity: These filters use media of panel style, and due to this, these filters have a small surface, which doesn’t let them eliminate huge amounts of airborne particles.
What Are Pleated Air Filters?
Pleated filters are designed with an expanded surface area, which allows them to capture more dust, pollen, and other airborne particles. The materials commonly used to make these filters, such as polypropylene, polyester, and nylon, are chosen for their strength and ability to withstand stress while maintaining efficient filtration. The increased surface area helps these filters trap more pollutants compared to simpler designs like fiberglass filters, making them more effective for maintaining cleaner indoor air.
With MERV ratings ranging from 8 to 13, pleated filters are capable of filtering out smaller particles, such as dust mites, pet dander, and mold spores, making them a great choice for homeowners who want improved air quality in their homes. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of pleated air filters:
Advantages
- Filtration Capacity: Pleated filters have a large surface area for filtration, and this capacity to remove contaminants from the air also increases. So these filters are best for apartments that have high amounts of airborne particles.
- Lifespan: The life of pleated filters is around 3 months or 90 days. Because of their longer lifespan, these filters will purify your home efficiently for a long time. But the life of a pleated filter depends on the condition of the house too. If your home has a lot of dust and dirt, these filters may need to be replaced sooner than you expect.
- High Quality: Pleated filters are made from high-quality synthetic materials and durable die-cut frames. These materials are strong and can withstand tough conditions, including high humidity.
- MERV Ratings: Pleated filters have MERV ratings between 8 and 13, which means they effectively capture small particles. The contaminants of size 1 micron or more are eliminated by these filters.
Disadvantages
- Cost: Pleated filters are generally more expensive than fiberglass filters, making them less budget-friendly for some individuals. While they offer higher filtration efficiency, their cost may be a consideration for those on a tighter budget.
- Airflow: The pleated filter’s design is very dense because the materials that are used to make them are dense (cotton or polyester). Airflow can be restricted with thick materials, and that can make your HVAC system work harder.
- Compatibility: Pleated filters may not be suitable for HVAC systems designed to handle low MERV rating filters. Their design and airflow restrictions require a high-quality HVAC system to function properly.
- Potential Release of VOCs: Pleated filters can sometimes release VOCs (volatile organic compounds) into the air, which may cause short- or long-term health issues for you and others in your home.
Comparison: Fiberglass vs. Pleated Air Filters
Now that we've explored the advantages and disadvantages of both filter types, the main question is, which one is the better choice? Here’s a quick comparative overview to help you decide.
| Features | Fiberglass Filters | Pleated Filters | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filtration Ability | Fiberglass filters can filter only large-sized particles of size more than 10 microns and are inefficient in eliminating small-sized particles like pollen, dust mites, mold spores, etc. | Pleated filters can remove both large and small particles effectively and capture particles of size between 1.0 and 10 microns, including pollen, mold spores, dust mites, etc. | Pleated Filters offer better filtration. |
| Cost | The cost of fiberglass filters is quite low. Its price ranges between $1 and $5. This makes it a budget-friendly option. | The cost of pleated filters can be expensive for many individuals because their price ranges between $5 and $15. | Fiberglass Filters are more affordable. |
| Lifespan | The life of fiberglass filters is very short. These filters only last for 30 days and sometimes even less. | The lifespan of pleated filters is quite good. These filters can last up to 90 days or 3 months, depending on the user’s indoor condition. | Pleated Filters last longer. |
| Availability | Fiberglass filters are easily available on the market and can be found in most of the local hardware stores. | Pleated filters are available in most of the local hardware stores, which makes them easy to purchase. | Both are easily available. |
| MERV Ratings | The MERV ratings of fiberglass filters are low. It ranges between 1 and 4. | MERV ratings of pleated filters are quite high, and they range between 8 and 13. | Pleated Filters offer better performance. |
| Airflow | The design of fiberglass filters provides good airflow to the HVAC system. | Pleated filters have a denser design that restricts the airflow, and this can make the HVAC system work harder. | Fiberglass Filters allow better airflow. |
| Compatibility | The fiberglass filters are compatible with most of the normal HVAC systems. | Pleated filters require a good-quality HVAC system that handles its airflow rates, so they are not compatible with normal HVAC systems. | Fiberglass Filters are more versatile. |
| Maintenance Frequency | The maintenance frequency of fiberglass filters is high because they need frequent new replacements. | Pleated filters don’t require much maintenance because of their longevity and require few replacements per year. | Pleated Filters require less maintenance. |
Additional Factors To Consider When Choosing An Air Filter
When choosing the best air filter for your needs, there are several important factors to consider. Whether you choose fiberglass or pleated filters, here are key points to help you make the right choice:
Air Quality
Consider the quality of your indoor air. If your home has poor air quality, a basic filter with low MERV ratings may not be enough to capture dust and other contaminants. For homes with relatively clean air, fiberglass filters may be sufficient. However, if your indoor air quality is poor and you need better filtration, a pleated filter would be a better choice.
Budget
Your budget plays a big role in your decision. Fiberglass filters are more affordable, making them a great option if you’re looking for a budget-friendly solution. Pleated filters, on the other hand, can be more expensive but offer superior filtration. If cost isn’t a major concern and you want more effective air purification, pleated filters are worth considering.
Health Concerns
If you or someone in your house has respiratory issues like asthma or allergies, the type of filter you choose becomes even more important. Pleated filters are designed to capture smaller particles like pollen, dust mites, and mold spores, which can be harmful to those with respiratory conditions. For better health protection, pleated filters are a great choice, especially if they are VOC-free, to avoid releasing harmful chemicals into the air. On the other hand, fiberglass filters may not provide the needed protection for individuals with medical concerns related to poor air quality.
Consider your budget, air quality needs, and health issue preferences to choose the right air filter.
Conclusion
When it comes to choosing the right air filter, both fiberglass and pleated filters offer unique benefits. Fiberglass filters are affordable and effective at trapping large particles, making them a good choice for basic air filtration. However, pleated filters, while more expensive, provide superior filtration by capturing both large and small particles, which is ideal for homes with poor air quality or health concerns.
Before making a decision, it’s important to consider factors like your budget, air quality needs, and the compatibility of the filter with your HVAC system. At Custom Filters Direct, we offer a range of filters with MERV ratings of 8, 11, and 13 to meet your specific air filtration needs. If you’re unsure which filter is best for you, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at (877) 812-7983 for guidance.
